5¢ Avg Carnival Prizes

Need to stock up on cheap prizes for your carnival games or party favors? Check out our selection of super cheap toys and novelties at American Carnival Mart. These inexpensive prizes and novelties are great for consolation prizes on Winner Every Time games. They range from just 2¢ each to less than 7¢ each, making the average price about 5¢ each when you select a variety of items. In addition to being cheap prizes for games, these toys also make great penny prizes for party activities, affordable party favors and fun freebies at doctor and dentist offices. Shop at American Carnival Mart today to get the best cheap carnival prizes for kids.

What does GR mean? Click here to see our Units of Measure Directory.

Sort By:
Candy & Toy Pinata Mix 4 lb

Candy & Toy Pinata Mix 4 lb

Item#: CA-PITA

$19.99 / BG (4 lb)

Crystal Ring

Crystal Ring

Item#: M0416

$9.00 / GR(144)

Fortune Teller Fish 3-1/2"

Fortune Teller Fish 3-1/2"

Item#: N448

$6.95 / GR(144)

Friendship Bracelet

Friendship Bracelet

Item#: M9625

$5.95 / GR(144)

Friendship Ring

Friendship Ring

Item#: M0403

$2.75 / GR(144)

Fringed Noisemakers 7"

Fringed Noisemakers 7"

Item#: NY24

$10.25 / GR(144)

Glitter Smile Face Rings

Glitter Smile Face Rings

Item#: C24-1204

$2.50 / UN (48)

Green Toy Soldiers 2"

Green Toy Soldiers 2"

Item#: M0320

$5.95 / GR(144)

Heart & Star Interlockers 1-1/2" Heart & Star Interlockers 1-1/2"

Heart & Star Interlockers 1-1/2"

Item#: T646A

$5.75 / GR(144)

Jumping 2" Plastic Frog

Jumping 2" Plastic Frog

Item#: M0224

$4.00 / GR(144)

Jumping Halloween Characters 1.5"

Jumping Halloween Characters 1.5"

Item#: EG110

$3.00 / GR(144)

Magnifying Glass 2-3/4"

Magnifying Glass 2-3/4"

Item#: M0246

$6.75 / GR(144)

Mini Smiley Face Eraser 3/4"

Mini Smiley Face Eraser 3/4"

Item#: TLM71

Temporarily out of Stock

Mini Top - Smile 1-1/4"

Mini Top - Smile 1-1/4"

Item#: M0201S

$4.95 / GR(144)

Mini Top - Swirl 1-1/4"

Mini Top - Swirl 1-1/4"

Item#: M0201

$4.50 / GR(144)

Mini Tops 1-1/2"

Mini Tops 1-1/2"

Item#: SL-STOP

$4.50 / GR(144)

Monster Teeth Assorted

Monster Teeth Assorted

Item#: M0500

$7.20 / GR(144)

Neon Jelly Bracelets

Neon Jelly Bracelets

Item#: M0205

Temporarily out of Stock

Pirate Coins

Pirate Coins

Item#: N1140

$5.25 / GR(144)

Plastic Gold Coins 1-1/4"

Plastic Gold Coins 1-1/4"

Item#: T578

$4.85 / GR(144)

Plastic Jumping Frogs 1.25" Plastic Jumping Frogs 1.25"

Plastic Jumping Frogs 1.25"

Item#: SL-PNJF

$6.00 / GR(144)

Plastic Mustache

Plastic Mustache

Item#: SL-MUST

$4.80 / GR(144)

Ruler Stencil 4"

Ruler Stencil 4"

Item#: M0223

$6.95 / GR(144)

Silver Plated Dollar Sign Rings 1.25" Silver Plated Dollar Sign Rings 1.25"

Silver Plated Dollar Sign Rings 1.25"

Item#: SL-SDRI

$9.00 / GR(144)

Need to stock up on cheap prizes for your carnival games or party favors? Check out our selection of super cheap toys and novelties at American Carnival Mart. These inexpensive prizes and novelties are great for consolation prizes on Winner Every Time games. They range from just 2¢ each to less than 7¢ each, making the average price about 5¢ each when you select a variety of items. In addition to being cheap prizes for games, these toys also make great penny prizes for party activities, affordable party favors and fun freebies at doctor and dentist offices. Shop at American Carnival Mart today to get the best cheap carnival prizes for kids.

What does GR mean? Click here to see our Units of Measure Directory.

1 - 24 of 53 items
1 - 24 of 53 items
Back to the Top